Table 1

- Subgroup analysis of ethnicity, saliva collection method, and participants’ symptoms.

SubgroupStudy (n)DORSensitivitySpecificityAUCNPVPPV
95% CIs
I2
Self-collected saliva (total)41196.20220.84760.98170.9550.94670.9404
[117.8833-326.5546][0.8045-0.8826][0.9707-0.9887][0.9130-0.9678][0.9122-0.9599]
82%87.3%89%96.4%83.2%
Regions
 North America20250.43210.87980.9807 0.96350.9275
[120.4677-520.6066][0.8182-0.9224][0.9646-0.9896] [0.9265-0.9822][0.8801-0.9571]
81.1%84.5%87.2% 94.1%81.1%
 Asia1292.30750.79380.9766 0.92830.9175
[35.8172-237.8934][0.6970-0.8656][0.9297-0.9924] [0.8056-0.9759][0.8410-0.9589]
85.6%87.1%94.7% 0.9283 [0.8056-0.9759]0.9175 [0.8410-0.9589]
 Europe6212.18210.80800.9852 0.91430.9676
[117.6169-382.7785][0.6984-0.8844][0.9751-0.9912] [0.7872-0.9685][0.9369-0.9836]
0%82.4%0% 95%30.9%
 South America2748.10440.88140.9924 0.91890.9839
[171.1188-3270.5945][0.7180-0.9559][0.9321-0.9992] [0.8642-0.9527][0.9378-0.9960]
0%71.2%35.1% 5.2%0%
 Oceania1269.50000.84620.9800 0.89090.9706
[31.0018-2342.7756][0.6974-0.9292][0.8712-0.9972] [0.7777-0.9502][0.8186-0.9959]
NANANA NANA
P-value 0.19790.3890.8652 0.28330.079
Collection method
 Only oral cavity saliva26215.15660.83650.9827 0.94960.9367
[110.2014-420.0706][0.7793-0.8812][0.9713-0.9896] [0.9111-0.9719][0.9007-0.9602]
84%87.4%84.4% 96.1%80.9%
 Only oral cavity saliva (not defined)8237.42460.89190.9820 0.97310.9173
[61.4927-916.7010][0.8432-0.9268][0.9035-0.9969] [0.9269-0.9904][0.7993-0.9686]
85.2%28.7%96.3% 89.7%86.0%
 Enhanced saliva7127.22540.83530.9779 0.88230.9654
[41.0992-393.8348][0.6844-0.9222][0.9338-0.9928] [0.6404-0.9693][0.9075-0.9875]
67.0%91.7%75.7% 2.084270.9%
P-value 0.70010.22820.928 0.21760.4355
Patient symptom
 Symptomatic22245.62220.88510.9791 0.95220.9495
[111.2860-542.1192][0.8497-0.9130][0.9580-0.9898] [0.9124-0.9744][0.9103-0.9721]
80.6%71.0%87.3% 92.2%80.3%
 Mixed15159.46380.82080.9783 0.91640.9435
[72.7019-349.7664][0.7399-0.8806][0.9588-0.9886] [0.8313-0.9606][0.9003-0.9687]
83.4%90.7%85.6% 97.0%82.4%
 Asymptomatic4184.89910.70490.9933 0.97720.8483
[44.5856-766.7872][0.4705-0.8653][0.9673-0.9987] [0.8563-0.9968][0.6869-0.9345]
80.3%82.3%92.3% 97.0%71.2%
P-value 0.74690.030.3924 0.3290.0879
  • DOR: diagnostic odds ratio, CI: confidence interval, AUC: area under the curve, NPV: negative predictive value, PPV: positive predictive value