Table 3

- Cochrane risk of bias assessment for included studies.

StudiesRandom sequence generationAllocation concealmentBlinding of participants and personnelBlinding of outcome assessmentIncomplete outcome dataSelective reportingOther bias
Bordini et al14LowLowHighHighLowLowHigh
Carlisle et al15UnclearUnclearHighHighLowLowHigh
Chien et al16UnclearUnclearLowHighHighLowHigh
Clifford et al17LowHighHighHighHighLowHigh
Corbett et al18LowUnclearHighHighHighLowHigh
Grahame et al19LowUnclearHighLowLowLowHigh
Ko et al20LowUnclearHighLowHighLowHigh
LaGasse et al21LowUnclearHighHighLowLowHigh
Levin et al22UnclearUnclearHighUnclearHighLowHigh
Thompson et al23LowLowHighHighLowLowHigh
Fletcher-Watson et al24LowLowHighHighHighLowHigh
Wood et al25UnclearUnclearHighLowHighLowHigh
Wood et al26LowLowHighHighHighLowHigh
Yoder et al27LowUnclearHighUnclearLowLowHigh
Young et al28LowUnclearHighLowHighLowLow
Zheng et al29LowUnclearHighUnclearLowLowHigh
Zhou et al30UnclearUnclearHighLowLowLowHigh