Abstract

Background

A prospective randomized multicentre study was performed to compare the outcome of laparoscopic and open appendicectomy in patients with suspected acute appendicitis.

Methods

A total of 523 patients was randomized, but because of 23 withdrawals the outcome in 500 patients is reported, 244 in the laparoscopic group and 256 in the open group.

Results

Patients having laparoscopic appendicectomy recovered more quickly than those having open surgery (13 versus 21 days, P < 0·001). There was no significant difference in duration of sick leave after operation (laparoscopic group 11 days versus open group 14 days). Postoperative pain (at 24 h, 7 days and 14 days) was less after laparoscopic operations and a functional index 1 week after operation was more favourable in these patients (P< 0·001). Operating time was significantly longer in the laparoscopic group (60 versus 35 min, P< 0·01). Hospital stay and complications did not differ between the groups. Thirty laparoscopic procedures (12 per cent) were converted to open appendicectomy.

Conclusion

Laparoscopic appendicectomy is as safe as open appendicectomy and has the advantage of allowing a quicker recovery.

References

1

Fitz
R
.
Perforating inflammation of the vermiform appendix, with special reference to its early diagnosis and treatment
.
Am J Med
1886
;
92
:
321
46
.

2

Pieper
R
,
Kager
L
,
Näsman
P
.
Acute appendicitis: a clinical study of 1018 cases of emergency appendectomy
.
Acta Chirurgica Scandinavica
1982
;
148
:
51
62
.

3

Blind
PJ
,
Dahlgren
ST
.
The continuing challenge of the negative appendix
.
Acta Chirurgica Scandinavica
1986
;
152
:
623
7
.

4

Chiarugi
M
,
Buccianti
P
,
Celona
G
,
Decanini
L
,
Martino
MC
,
Goletti
O
et al. 
Laparoscopic compared with open appendicectomy for acute appendicitis: a prospective study
.
Eur J Surg
1996
;
162
:
385
90
.

5

Jeffrey
RB
,
Laing
FC
,
Townsend
RR
.
Acute appendicitis: sonographic criteria based on 250 cases
.
Radiology
1988
;
167
:
327
9
.

6

Eriksson
S
,
Granström
L
,
Carlström
A
.
The diagnostic value of repetitive preoperative analyses of C-reactive protein and total leucocyte count in patients with suspected acute appendicitis
.
Scand J Gastroenterol
1994
;
29
:
1145
9
.

7

de Dombal
FT
,
Leaper
DJ
,
Staniland
JR
,
McCann
AP
,
Horrocks
JC
.
Computer-aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain
.
BMJ
1972
;
ii
:
9
13
.

8

Fenyö
G
.
Routine use of a scoring system for decision-making in suspected acute appendicitis in adults
.
Acta Chirurgica Scandinavica
1987
;
153
:
545
51
.

9

Alvarado
A
.
A practical score for the early diagnosis of acute appendicitis
.
Ann Emerg Med
1986
;
15
:
557
64
.

10

Andersson
RE
,
Hugander
A
,
Thulin
AJG
.
Diagnostic accuracy and perforation rate in appendicitis: association with age and sex of the patient and with appendicectomy rate
.
Eur J Surg
1992
;
158
:
37
41
.

11

Lewis
FR
,
Holcroft
JW
,
Boey
J
,
Dunphy
JE
.
Appendicitis: a critical review of diagnosis and treatment in 1000 cases
.
Arch Surg
1975
;
110
:
677
84
.

12

Chang
FC
,
Hogle
HH
,
Welling
DR
.
The fate of the negative appendix
.
Am J Surg
1973
;
126
:
752
4
.

13

Cuschieri
A
,
Dubois
F
,
Moujel
J
,
Mouret
P
,
Becker
H
,
Buess
G
et al. 
The European experience with laparoscopic cholecystectomy
.
Am J Surg
1991
;
161
:
385
8
.

14

Hinder
RA
,
Filipi
CJ
,
Wetscher
G
,
Neary
P
,
DeMeester
TR
,
Perdikis
G
.
Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is an effective treatment for gastroesophageal reflux disease
.
Ann Surg
1994
;
220
:
472
83
.

15

Kald
A
.
Audit of groin hernia repair. Medical dissertation
. University of Linköping:
1997
.

16

Semm
K
.
Endoscopic appendectomy
.
Endoscopy
1983
;
15
:
59
64
.

17

Attwood
SEA
,
Hill
ADK
,
Murphy
PG
,
Thornton
J
,
Stephens
RB
.
A prospective randomized trial of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy
.
Surgery
1992
;
112
:
497
501
.

18

Martin
LC
,
Puente
I
,
Sosa
JL
,
Bassin
A
,
Breslaw
R
,
McKenney
MG
et al. 
Open versus laparoscopic appendectomy. A prospective randomized comparison
.
Ann Surg
1995
;
222
:
256
62
.

19

Hansen
JB
,
Smithers
BM
,
Schache
D
,
Wall
DR
,
Miller
BJ
,
Menzies
BL
.
Laparoscopic versus open appendectomy: prospective randomized trial
.
World J Surg
1996
;
20
:
17
21
.

20

Richards
W
,
Watson
D
,
Lynch
G
,
Reed
GW
,
Olsen
D
,
Spaw
A
et al. 
A review of the results of laparoscopic versus open appendectomy
.
Surg Gynecol Obstet
1993
;
177
:
473
80
.

21

Cox
MR
,
McCall
JL
,
Toouli
J
,
Padbury
TA
,
Wilson
TG
,
Wattchow
DA
et al. 
Prospective randomized comparison of open versus laparoscopic appendectomy in men
.
World J Surg
1996
;
20
:
263
6
.

22

Reiertsen
O
,
Larsen
S
,
Trondsen
E
,
Edwin
B
,
Faerden
AE
,
Rosseland
AR
.
Randomized controlled trial with sequential design of laparoscopic versus conventional appendicectomy
.
Br J Surg
1997
;
84
:
842
7
.

23

Lujan Mompean
JA
,
Robles Campos
R
,
Parilla Paricio
P
,
Soria Aledo
V
,
Garcia Ayllon
J
.
Laparoscopic versus open appendectomy: a prospective assessment
.
Br J Surg
1994
;
81
:
133
5
.

24

Vallina
VL
,
Velasco
JM
,
McCulloch
CS
.
Laparoscopic versus conventional appendectomy
.
Ann Surg
1993
;
218
:
685
92
.

25

Apelgren
KN
,
Molnar
RG
,
Kisala
JM
.
Laparoscopic is not better than open appendectomy
.
Am Surg
1995
;
61
:
240
3
.

26

Majeed
AW
,
Troy
G
,
Nicholl
JP
,
Smythe
A
,
Reed
MW
,
Stoddard
CJ
et al. 
Randomised, prospective, single-blind comparison of laparoscopic versus small-incision cholecystectomy
.
Lancet
1996
;
347
:
989
94
.

27

Tate
JJT
,
Chung
SCS
,
Dawson
J
,
Leong
HT
,
Chan
A
,
Lau
WY
et al. 
Conventional versus laparoscopic surgery for acute appendicitis
.
Br J Surg
1993
;
80
:
761
4
.

28

Ortega
AE
,
Hunter
JG
,
Peters
JH
,
Swanstrom
LL
,
Schirmer
BA
.
A prospective randomized comparison of laparoscopic appendectomy with open appendectomy
. Laparoscopic Appendectomy Study Group.
Am J Surg
1995
;
169
:
208
13
.

29

Kum
CK
,
Ngoi
SS
,
Goh
PMY
,
Tekant
Y
,
Isaac
JR
.
Randomized controlled trial comparing laparoscopic and open appendicectomy
.
Br J Surg
1993
;
80
:
1599
600
.

30

Pier
A
,
Gotz
F
,
Bacher
C
.
Laparoscopic appendectomy in 625 cases: from innovation to routine
.
Surg Laparosc Endosc
1991
;
1
:
8
13
.

31

Valla
JS
,
Limonne
B
,
Valla
V
,
Montupet
P
,
Daoud
N
,
Grinda
A
et al. 
Laparoscopic appendectomy in children: report of 465 cases
.
Surg Laparosc Endosc
1991
;
1
:
166
72
.

32

Peters
JH
,
Ellison
EC
,
Innes
JT
,
Liss
JL
,
Nichols
KE
,
Lomano
JM
et al. 
Safety and efficacy of laparoscopic cholecystectomy. A prospective analysis of 100 initial patients
.
Ann Surg
1991
;
213
:
3
12
.

33

Kollias
J
,
Harries
RHC
,
Otto
G
,
Hamilton
DW
,
Cox
JST
,
Gallery
RM
.
Laparoscopic versus open appendicectomy for suspected appendicitis: a prospective study
.
Aust N Z J Surg
1994
;
64
:
830
5
.

34

Tang
E
,
Ortega
AE
,
Anthone
GJ
,
Beart
RW
.
Intraabdominal abscesses following laparoscopic and open appendectomies
.
Surg Endosc
1996
;
10
:
327
8
.

This content is only available as a PDF.
This article is published and distributed under the terms of the Oxford University Press, Standard Journals Publication Model (https://academic.oup.com/journals/pages/open_access/funder_policies/chorus/standard_publication_model)