Abstract
Objectives: To identify predictors of recurrent arteriovenous fistula (AVF) stenosis. It also seeks to calculate the average primary patency duration in Saudi patients undergoing hemodialysis.
Methods: A retrospective case-control study was conducted at a tertiary care hospital in Riyadh. Data from 180 patients who had undergone angioplasty between May 2009 and May 2020 were analyzed. Following the inclusion/exclusion criteria, 99 patients were included. Based on the presence or absence of recurrent AVF stenosis, the patients were divided into cases and controls, respectively. Recurrence was defined as an occurrence of stenosis within <12 months of a previous stenotic event, or patients who had >3 total stenotic events. Clinical, radiological, and laboratory variables were collected and subjected to multivariate binary regression analysis to assess the odds of a recurrence of fistula stenosis.
Results: A total of 29 patients were categorized as cases, while 70 patients were categorized as controls. The median primary patency duration was found to be seven months. Multivariate binary regression analysis revealed higher levels of serum calcium (p=0.012) and BMI (p=0.007) in patients with recurrent stenosis. A positive association was also observed between the use of antiplatelets (0.039) and recurrent stenosis.
Conclusion: Higher levels of corrected calcium, BMI, and the application of antiplatelet therapy were found to be predictors of recurrent AVF stenosis. No other traditional variables were found to be significant.
The global prevalence of chronic kidney disease (CKD) in all its stages was 13.4% in 2016.1 The treatment of the most severe form of CKD, also known as, end stage renal disease (ESRD), mandated the inclusion of a type of renal replacement therapy within their management plan. These include kidney transplantation, peritoneal dialysis, and hemodialysis.2 Of which, Hemodialysis is the most common. Vascular access in patients undergoing hemodialysis is achieved through a central venous catheter, arteriovenous grafts, or arteriovenous fistulas (AVF). Arteriovenous fistulas are usually the recommended type of vascular access by the National Kidney Foundation.3 Arteriovenous fistulas are usually created when long-term hemodialysis access is required. The main types of AVF are radial-cephalic, brachial-cephalic, and brachial-basilic fistulas.4
One of the most common problems that hemodialysis patients face is vascular access dysfunction.5 It was also found that stenosis, which comprises 78% of all cases of early AVF dysfunction, is the main cause of AVF dysfunction.6 Arteriovenous fistula stenosis is characterized by a reduction of the normal vessel diameter by more than 50%, and is usually treated with angioplasty of the fistula.5 The importance of a patent AVF has led to research on determining possible predictors associated with the incidence of recurrent AVF stenosis, which has variable definitions across studies.7 For example, a study carried out by Nevez et al,7 who defined recurrent stenosis as any stenosis occurring within 180 days of the initial angioplasty, found that diabetes and residual stenosis after the initial index angioplasty, even though fewer than 30%, were predictive of recurrent stenosis.8 According to a study carried out in 2021, The number of Saudi patients undergoing hemodialysis is estimated to be 20,000. While the combined prevalence of patients undergoing renal replacement therapy in Saudi Arabia is estimated at 294.3 per million population.9 Unfortunately, studies targeting recurrent stenosis are scarce on the Saudi Arabian hemodialysis population. So, this study may identify predictors and variables concerning the hemodialysis population in Saudi Arabia that might aid in the management of Saudi patients undergoing hemodialysis. The objective of this study was to identify predictors of recurrent AVF stenosis in hemodialysis patients.
Methods
The objectives of this study required the use of a retrospective case-control design, through which the required data was gathered using electronic medical records and radiological reporting systems available at the hospital. Data were collected from 180 patients admitted from May 2009 to May 2020 to the interventional radiology unit due to AVF stenosis.
The participants chosen for inclusion in this study were i) patients aged 18–70 years, ii) patients undergoing chronic hemodialysis, and iii) patients with a brachiocephalic, radiocephalic, or brachiobasilic fistula. The exclusion criteria were patients i) had a fistula fail before undergoing a dialysis session, and ii) patients who did not have regular follow-ups in the hospital. Due to the lack of an established definition of “recurrent stenosis,” the definition used in this study is either 3 stenoses events or a stenosis event that occurred within 12 months of the initial index angioplasty. The cases had recurrent stenosis, while the controls did not develop it.
As a result of applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 81 patients were excluded, leaving 99 patients who underwent angioplasty. in the interventional radiology department. Indications of angioplasty included decreased blood flow during hemodialysis session, stenosis more than 60% of lumen at the site of arteriovenous anastomosis or at drainage vein site. A total of 200 angioplasties were included in our analysis. The sample patients’ notes, lab values, and relevant clinical information were acquired from the statistical logbook after obtaining approval from the hospital’s Institutional Review Board. The data collected on their fistulas were the date of the first angioplasty to be used as the index procedure, the type of fistula, the date of the subsequent angioplasty, the total stenoses the patient had experienced, and the history of fistula abandonment. Most of the angioplasties were plain Balloon angioplasties. However, the angioplasties performed on patients with recurrent stenosis or central venous stenosis employed high-pressure and drug coated balloons as well as the usage of stents. Some details regarding the first angioplasty assessing the lesion’s severity, such as the degree of severity and the location of the stenosis, were included within the variables. To determine if there was a correlation between these outcomes and the evaluated predictors, the patients’ age, gender, smoking status, body mass index (BMI), angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor therapy, antiplatelet therapy, the presence of diabetes, dyslipidemia, and coronary or peripheral arterial disease were examined. The laboratory predictors were hemoglobin levels, albumin, corrected calcium, phosphorus, C-reactive protein, vitamin D levels, and hemoglobin A1C levels in people who are diabetic. Due to the chronic process through which stenosis occurs, these factors were monitored and collected as the average of the last 3 readings within a year of the first stenotic event.
Statistical analysis
Mean and standard deviation were used to describe continuous measured variables, while frequency and percentages were used to describe categorically measured variables. While the Mann-Whitney U non-parametric test was used to assess the statistical significance on metric variables with skewness between patients with and without recurrent stenosis. The histogram and the statistical Kolmogorov–Smirnov test were used to assess the normality assumption of continuous variables. Levene’s test of homogeneity of variance was used to evaluate the equality of variance statistical assumption. The Chi-squared (χ2) test of association was used to assess the associations among categorically measured variables. Continuity-adjusted Chi-squared tests and associated p-values were quoted when the statistical assumption of observed counts below expected was noted for contingency tables. An independent samples t-test was used to assess the statistical mean differences of metric variables across the levels of binary categorically measured variables. Multiple response dichotomy analysis was applied to describe the variables with more than one option (such as, medical history and the reasons for ESRD). Multivariate binary regression analysis was used to assess the statistical significance of the predictors of the patients’ odds of having recurrent fistula stenosis. The association between the patients’ sociodemographic and disease-related factors and recurrent fistula stenosis events was expressed as an odds ratio with an associated 95% confidence interval. The alpha significance level was considered at the 0.050 level, and the commercially available SPSS version 21 (IBMCorp, Armonk, NY, USA) statistical analysis program was used for the data analysis. Bivariate analysis methods were also used to better understand the cause of recurrence of AVF stenosis among the sample of patients A total of 99 patients with AVFs were reviewed retrospectively.
Results
The resulting analysis showed that 50.5% were female patients and 49.5% were male patients. The mean age (years) of the sample of patients was 53.04 years (standard deviation [SD]=11.86 years). The patients in the study had a mean BMI (body mass index) of 29.47 (SD=7.89), and the majority (43.4%) were obese. The results of the analysis of the patient’s type of fistula, severity, location of stenosis of the index angioplasty, and data on the chronology of the stenotic event is displayed in (Table 1). The most common cause of ESRD was diabetic nephropathy (52.5%). Reviewing the medical and therapeutic history of the patients also showed that most of them (43.4%) were taking antiplatelet agents, while some (12.1%) were taking angiotensin converting enzyme/angiotensin-receptor blockers (ACE/ARB) agents. Furthermore, 58.6% of the patients had a positive medical diagnosis of diabetes mellitus. Regarding the type of AVF, the findings showed that most of the patients (57.6%) had a brachiocephalic fistula, (34.3%) had a radiocephalic fistula, and 8% had a brachiobasilic fistula. A total of 37.4% of the patients in the sample developed a second AVF stenosis event, with a median duration between the first and second fistula stenosis of 7 months. Accordingly, 75th percentile analysis showed that most of the patients (75% of those who experienced a second stenosis) had been symptom free for at least 14 months before experiencing a second stenosis. It was also observed that even fewer patients (21.2%) experienced a third stenosis event requiring medical intervention after their first and second stenoses. Among the patients with tertiary stenosis, the median duration of time between secondary and tertiary stenoses was 6.54 months, but most patients (75% of those with tertiary stenosis) experienced their third stenosis event after 14–16 event-free months on average. According to the definition of recurrent fistula stenosis, 29.3% (n=29) of the patients were considered to have had recurrent AVF stenosis and were classified as cases. While 70.7% (n=70) of the patients were classified as controls. The time between recurrent fistula stenosis was equal to the median value of 4.5 months, but quartile analysis findings showed that most of the patients (75%) acquired a secondary stenosis within 11.5 months. The medical record review also showed that 14.1% of the patients included in this sample previously had abandoned fistulas.
Descriptive analysis of the patient’s arteriovenous fistula characteristics.
The results of the bivariate analysis on data of the patients’ demographics and past medical history are shown in (Table 2). The table shows that the patients’ gender, age, BMI score, and obesity classification did not significantly correlate with their likelihood of recurrent fistula stenosis. While an independent t-test indicated that the BMI of patients with and without recurrent fistula stenosis differed slightly, the difference was not statistically significant. Those with recurrent stenosis had slightly higher BMI scores (mean=31.66, SD=8.72) on average than those without recurrent dialysis fistula stenosis (mean BMI=28.53, SD=7.32, p=0.070). The findings from the bivariate analysis indicated that patients’ smoking habits and causes of initiation of hemodialysis did not significantly correlate with the patient’s likelihood of recurrent dialysis fistula stenosis. In addition, the patients’ use of ACE/ARB inhibitor agents was not significantly associated with their likelihood of having recurrent fistula stenosis. The patients’ use of antiplatelet therapeutic agents, though, significantly increased the likelihood of recurrent AV fistula stenosis (p=0.050). Moreover, the results of the Bivariate analysis of the patients’ data regarding the chronology and severity of their stenoses is shown on Table 3. Interestingly, the table shows that the patients’ type of fistula, severity of the index stenosis, and average lab values also did not significantly correlate with their likelihood of recurrent fistula stenosis.
The statistical data analysis was further shown by a decrease in the patients’ odds of recurrent AVF stenosis in accordance with the patients’ sociodemographic characteristics and other relevant predictors that were measured for the study. Table 4 shows that despite accounting for the other predictor variables in the analysis model, age, and gender did not significantly correlate with recurrences of AVF stenoses. While the patients’ BMI scores positively and significantly correlated with the odds of their having recurrent AVF stenosis events, as the patients’ BMI scores rose by one point on average, their odds of having recurrent stenoses rose by 1.11 times, or 11% times more than patients who had lower BMI scores. It should be noted that Figure 1 shows the patients’ BMI classification on the X-axis, and the model predicting the mean propensity of recurrent AVF stenosis on the Y-axis, as the patients’ BMIs were underweight, normal, overweight, and obese. The predicted likelihood of recurrent AVF stenosis rose on average. Obese patients were most likely to experience a recurrent stenosis of the AVF, while underweight patients were least likely to experience it. Interestingly, it was also found that the patients using antiplatelet agents had correlated with a higher chance of developing recurrent AVF stenosis (p=0.039). After controlling for the other predictors, the patients taking antiplatelet drugs were therefore significantly (3.064 times) more likely to develop recurrent AVF stenosis than those who did not take these agents (p=0.039). A positive history of diabetes and dyslipidemia, as well as the type of fistula, did not significantly impact the chances of recurrent fistula stenosis events. Moreover, the multivariate analysis results showed that the patients’ overall mean serum corrected calcium levels correlated significantly and positively with their chances of experiencing recurrent AVF stenosis. As the mean serum calcium level of patients who were in the cases group was higher than the average calculated for the control group by 0.11 mmol/L, the corresponding odds of developing recurrent stenosis increased by 15.01 times on average (p=0.012) once the other predictors in the analysis model were considered. The explanation of the corrected calcium’s rebel odds ratio is the variability in patients average serum calcium readings. Where some controls were found to have low calcium compared to other controls whose average calcium reading was high in the period prior to the index stenosis. As a result, this imposed uncertainty as such the odds ratio is inflated and the confidence interval is widened
Bivariate analysis on data of the patient’s demographic and past medical history.
- Bivariate analysis of the patients’ data on the chronology and severity of their stenoses.
Multivariate binary logistic regression analysis of the sample patients’ odds of recurrent fistula stenosis (N=99).
The association between patients body mass index (BMI) classification with their model predicted probability of predicted stenosis.
Discussion
This study’s objectives were to identify predictors of recurrent AVF stenosis in hemodialysis patients and to calculate the average primary patency rate between the first and second stenosis. The data analysis suggested that the median primary patency duration was 7 months, which is lower than the average primary patency duration found elsewhere in previous studies. For example, a systematic review found that the average primary patency rates in different regions worldwide varied between 10.5 and 41 months.10 It was also indicated that the strongest predictor of recurrent AVF stenosis was higher levels of corrected serum calcium and that patients with a higher mean of corrected calcium were 15.01 more times likely to experience recurrent stenosis. The exact mechanism through which this occurs is still largely unknown. There is a possibility that it can be a direct influencer of the rate at which vascular calcification occurs. This association has not been linked to AVF stenosis specifically in the literature, but it has been implicated in incidences of cerebral, coronary, and transplanted renal artery stenosis.11-13 The variability of patients corrected calcium levels caused the average calcium reading to have a large odds ratio and a wide confidence interval. This variability is likely attributed to hemodialysis itself which resulted in the average readings among the sample patients to largely differ. Although the patients in our sample with lower corrected calcium measurements had a lower risk of recurrent stenosis, the generalizability of this finding is limited. More research is necessary to reach a more solid conclusion.
It was also found that BMI correlates significantly and positively with recurrent AVF stenosis. A possible explanation is that obese patients undergo more aggressive intimal hyperplasia, which leads to earlier occurrences of stenosis.14 The average BMI of the sample was classified as overweight to obese (29.47), meaning that a large number of the patients in the sample had this risk factor. Consequently, more aggressive measures of weight loss interventions, such as liberal referrals to dietitians and weight loss clinics, may limit the occurrence of recurrent stenosis in this patient population. The incidence of earlier stenoses can also be counteracted by increasing the initial luminal diameter with hand grip exercises, as some studies have suggested.15 Another significant intervention that may reduce the incidence of recurring stenotic events is employing the use of drug coated balloons (DCB) instead of plain balloon angioplasties (PBA). A study by Troisi et al,16 found a significant increase in the time to restenosis when the angioplasty was carried out using DCB’s compared to PBA’s.
Interestingly, the use of antiplatelet therapy correlated with an increased incidence of recurrent AVF stenosis. This finding contradicts many studies on this topic, since antiplatelets have been found to prevent stenosis.17 Although a study by Murley et al18 on 670 patients demonstrated no change in the risk of fistula dysfunction with antiplatelet usage, another study was discontinued due to an increased risk of bleeding observed in the patient sample.19 The association found in this study might be explained by patients on antiplatelet therapy having an inherently increased risk of coagulation. Antiplatelets are usually prescribed to patients with an increased stratified risk of adverse vascular events. The findings of our study may mean that hemodialysis patients should have a lower threshold for vascular screening procedures since they may be more susceptible to adverse vascular events. Further studies on the risk of adverse vascular events in the hemodialysis population are necessary to verify these findings. The use of ACE inhibitors/ARB’s was not associated with a change in the risk of recurrent stenosis. This finding is consistent with Heine et al’s20 study, in which the effect of ACE inhibitor usage did not consistently correlate with a decreased risk of fistula dysfunction.
Study limitations
This study has a low sample size due to the nature of the study and the target population, which may have affected its statistical power. Another limitation was the lack of patient information when collecting levels of C-reactive protein, and vitamin D because it was not ordered as liberally for patients undergoing angioplasty. Data regarding location and severity of stenosis, and the types of balloons used for each procedure was also unreported in most patients’ post-procedural notes. However, most of the patients’ data were complete.
A similar study carried out by Aktas et al,21 which included 330 patients, found that the patient’s age and the presence of diabetes mellitus were significant predictors of early fistula stenosis. Although these variables were considered in this study’s analysis, they were not found to be significantly associated with recurrent stenosis. This finding may be due to the limitations mentioned earlier.
In conclusion, AVF stenosis is one of many complications that adds to the burden of CKD. This study found that the median primary patency duration between the first and second AVF stenosis was seven months, and that several predictors contributed to the occurrence of stenosis in Saudi patients, including high BMI, elevated serum corrected calcium levels, and the use of antiplatelet therapy. The lack of significant predictors in previous studies, such as age, diabetes, and residual stenosis, can likely be attributed to low sample sizes and subsequent study power. Further studies are necessary to reach a more definitive conclusion.
Acknowledgment
The authors gratefully acknowledge SCREBBER (www.Scribber.com) for English language editing.
Footnotes
Disclosure. Authors have no conflict of interests, and the work was not supported or funded by any drug company.
- Received March 6, 2022.
- Accepted May 17, 2022.
- Copyright: © Saudi Medical Journal
This is an Open Access journal and articles published are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (CC BY-NC). Readers may copy, distribute, and display the work for non-commercial purposes with the proper citation of the original work.
References
In this issue
Jump to section
Related Articles
Cited By...
- No citing articles found.